My favorite fuel cells burn hydrogen-rich hydrocarbon fuels, like methane (natural gas) instead of pure hydrogen. Methane is far more energy dense, and costs far less than hydrogen per energy content. The US has plenty of methane and has pipelines that distribute it to every city and town. It’s a low CO₂ fuel, and we can lower the CO₂ impact further by mixing in hydrogen to get hythane. Elon Musk has called hydrogen- powered fuel cells “fool cells”, methane-powered fuel cells look a lot less foolish. They easily compete with his batteries and with gasoline. Besides, Musk has chosen methane as the fuel for his proposed starship to Mars.

Solid oxide fuel cells, SOFCs, can use methane directly without any pre-reformer. They operate at 800°C or so. At these temperatures, methane reacts with water (steam) within the fuel cell to form hydrogen by the reaction, CH₄ + H₂O –> 3H₂ + CO. The hydrogen, and to a lesser extent the CO is oxidized in the fuel cell to create electricity,, but the methane is not 100% consumed, generally. Unused methane, CO, and some hydrogen exits a solid oxide fuel cell along with the products of combustion, CO₂ and water.

Several researchers have looked for ways to recycle this waste fuel to capture the energy value. Six years ago, I patented a membrane method to extract the waste fuel and recycle it, see a description here. I now see this method as too complex, and have applied for a patent on a simpler version, shown below as Figure 1. As before the main work is done by a membrane but here I dispense with the water gas shift reactor, and many of the heat exchangers of the previous approach.

The fuel cell system of Fig. 1 operates at somewhat elevated pressure, 2 atm or more. It is expected that the majority of the exhaust going to the membrane will be CO₂ and water. Most of this will pass through the membrane and will exhaust to the air. The rest is mixed with fresh methane and recycles to the fuel cell. Despite the pressure of the fuel cell, very a little energy is needed for recirculation since the methane does not go through the membrane. The result is a light, simple, and energy efficient process. If you are interested, please contact me at REB Research. Or you can purchase the silicone membrane module here. Alternately, see here for flux information and other applications.

Robert Buxbaum, December 8, 2022.